The effects of table lamp shade shape and compact fluorescent lamp burning position on university students' visual comfort



Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title


Texas Tech University


To increase consumers' support of and market for compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) retrofits in table lamps, visual comfort and task illumination distribution were assessed. The principal purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of shade shape and CFL burning position on visual comfort. The second purpose of this study was to develop and evaluate a Comfort Scale (CS) for measuring table lamp users' visual comfort. One hundred and twenty university students volunteered to participate in the study, and ninety responses from students with 20/20 or corrected vision were used in the data analyses. For each of six conditions, fifteen students performed a visual task and completed a CS and a University Students' Survey (USS). Round, square, and polygon shades and a vertical and a horizontal CFL were tested. A GE™ light meter was used to measure task illumination. Validity of the instruments and procedures was determined by dissertation committee opinion, literature review, and factor analysis. Reliability of the scales was determined by Cronbach's alpha.

MANOVA indicated that shade shape affects visual comfort and task illumination. MANOVA demonstrated that CFL burning position affects visual comfort and task illumination. MANOVA also established that the interaction of shade shape and CFL burning position affects visual factors of comfort (preference, comfort, and brightness condition).

Lighting designers can select a shade appropriate for the type of CFL specified. Lighting manufacturers need to disseminate information regarding Mil shades and CFL burning positions so that consumers will be able to make appropriate choices. Future research needs to consider the effect of shade factors and various CFL types on other applications. Understanding the effect of a table lamp fixture on the users' well-being can accelerate the confidence in and use of CFLs by consumers.



Fluorescent lamps, Physiological optics, Lampshades, Fluorescent lighting